Skip to content
Small Town PagesGet listed free
Downtown Shelter Island, New York

Shelter Island, NY

93 local businesses in and around Suffolk County. Locally owned first. Every listing dated.

Popular in Shelter Island

Featured in Shelter Island

How to get featured

Your business here

Only 3 Featured spots per category in Shelter Island.

Recently checked in Shelter Island

Restaurants and Catering

18 Bay

23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

(631) 749-0053

Not yet verified

Browse Shelter Island by category

Home services

PlumbersNone yet. Add the first oneElectriciansNone yet. Add the first oneHeating and AirNone yet. Add the first oneRoofingNone yet. Add the first oneContractors and BuildersNone yet. Add the first oneLawn and Landscaping3 listingsCleaning ServicesNone yet. Add the first onePest ControlNone yet. Add the first onePool Service1 listingLocksmithsNone yet. Add the first oneHome InspectorsNone yet. Add the first oneStorage UnitsNone yet. Add the first oneLaundromats and Dry CleaningNone yet. Add the first one

Auto

Auto Repair3 listingsAuto Dealers1 listingAuto PartsNone yet. Add the first oneGas Stations3 listings

Food and drink

Restaurants and Catering14 listingsCafes and Bakeries2 listingsBars and Pubs4 listingsGrocery and Markets5 listings

Shopping

Shopping and Gifts3 listingsPawn ShopsNone yet. Add the first onePhones and ComputersNone yet. Add the first oneGuns and OutdoorsNone yet. Add the first oneClothing and Shoes2 listingsHardware and Farm Supply2 listingsFurniture and Home GoodsNone yet. Add the first oneFlorists1 listing

Health and beauty

Salons, Nails and BarbersNone yet. Add the first oneDoctors and Clinics4 listingsDentists1 listingCounseling and TherapyNone yet. Add the first oneSenior Living and Home CareNone yet. Add the first onePharmaciesNone yet. Add the first oneGyms and Fitness1 listingVets and Pet Care1 listing

Professional

Real Estate6 listingsInsurance1 listingLawyers1 listingBail BondsNone yet. Add the first onePrinting and Signs1 listingAccountants, Tax and NotaryNone yet. Add the first oneBanks and Credit Unions3 listings

Community

Churches5 listingsSchools and Childcare1 listingColleges and Trade SchoolsNone yet. Add the first oneWeddings and EventsNone yet. Add the first oneCity and Public Services5 listingsFuneral Homes1 listingHotels and Lodging13 listingsFun and Entertainment3 listingsOther Local Businesses2 listings

Long Island and Downstate

About local business in Shelter Island

Shelter Island is a town of about 3,300 people in Suffolk County, Long Island and Downstate. Small Town Pages lists 93 businesses here, and 89 of them are locally owned. The most listed kinds are restaurants and catering (14), hotels and lodging (13) and real estate (6). 76 list a phone number and 4 post their hours.

Nearby towns

Questions about Shelter Island

How many local businesses are listed in Shelter Island, NY?

93 businesses are listed in Shelter Island across 29 categories. 89 are locally owned, and 4 national brands are shown after them. Listings were last checked in September 2026.

What kinds of businesses can I find in Shelter Island?

The most listed are restaurants and catering (14), hotels and lodging (13), real estate (6), grocery and markets (5), churches (5) and city and public services (5). Every category has its own page for Shelter Island.

Which towns near Shelter Island are on Small Town Pages?

Southold (5 miles), East Hampton (11 miles), Old Saybrook (16 miles), Westbrook (17 miles) and Old Lyme (17 miles). Many local businesses serve more than one town.

Do businesses in Shelter Island offer military, senior or first responder discounts?

None have posted one yet. Owners can add military, senior, first responder and other discounts to their listing free.

How do I add or fix a business in Shelter Island?

Owners can claim their listing free and update the phone, hours and photos. Anyone can add a business we are missing with the Add a business form, and a person checks it before it goes up.

Own a business in Shelter Island?

Find your listing and claim it free. Not here yet? Add it, and anyone can add a business they know.

Claim your listingAdd a missing business