Skip to content
Small Town PagesGet listed free

Hotels and Lodging in Shelter Island, NY

13 local businesses. Hotels, motels and cabins. 7 list a phone number. Nearby: Southold has 33 (5 mi), East Hampton has 66 (11 mi) and Old Saybrook has 11 (16 mi).

Featured hotels and lodging in Shelter Island

3 of 3 spots open

This spot is open

Be one of only 3 featured hotels and lodging in Shelter Island.

Claim a Featured spot

Local businesses

Hotels and Lodging in nearby towns

Questions about Hotels and Lodging in Shelter Island

How many businesses are listed under Hotels and Lodging in Shelter Island, NY?

13 are listed. 13 are locally owned.

Which Hotels and Lodging businesses in Shelter Island are locally owned?

Candle Lite Inn & Guest House, Dering Harbor Inn, Four West Neck, Ram's Head Inn and Sunset Beach Resort, plus 8 more on this page.

How do I contact Hotels and Lodging businesses in Shelter Island?

7 of 13 list a phone number, 7 list a website. Each listing shows the date it was last checked.

Are there more Hotels and Lodging listings near Shelter Island?

Yes. Southold has 33 (5 miles), East Hampton has 66 (11 miles), Old Saybrook has 11 (16 miles), Westbrook has 5 (17 miles) and Old Lyme has 3 (17 miles).

Is a business like this in Shelter Island missing or out of date?

Owners can claim a listing free to fix the phone, hours and photos. Anyone can add a missing business, and a person checks it before it goes up.